On Monday 9 November, student reps from across the Humanities Division spent an hour with the Vice-Chancellor, Professor Irene Tracey, at the Schwarzman Centre.
WRITTEN BY
KSKyle Siwek
Humanities Postgraduate Research Div Rep
View profile GVGiulia Villa
Humanities Postgraduate Taught Div Rep
View profile Humanities student reps meet the Vice-Chancellor, Professor Irene Tracey, and Professor Daniel Grimley at the Schwarzman Centre, Monday 9 November.
Photo: Michael-Akolade Ayodeji
On Monday 9 November, student reps from across the Humanities Division spent an hour with the Vice-Chancellor, Professor Irene Tracey, at the Schwarzman Centre. Professor Daniel Grimley, Head of the Humanities Division, chaired the meeting, and they were joined by Alex Vincent, Divisional Registrar and Chief Operating Officer for the Humanities Division. The meeting was informal and student-led. All three Humanities div reps were in the room. The Division asked reps beforehand what they wanted to cover, and Kyle was one of the reps who suggested topics.
An open door for student views
What stood out most was how open the conversation was. Reps did not hold back, raising challenges as well as ideas, and the Vice-Chancellor welcomed it. She was clear that hearing from students is central to how the University shapes its approach, from AI policy to how the new building is used, and she asked reps to keep speaking up, in meetings like this one and beyond. As she put it:
"You are the best people to inform us as to what's going to work for you."
Professor Irene Tracey, Vice-Chancellor
Professor Grimley made the same point: students' input is central to the Division's work, and he asked reps to help by starting these conversations in their faculties and bringing people together.
The Vice-Chancellor, Professor Irene Tracey, answers reps' questions.
Photo: Michael-Akolade Ayodeji
AI took centre stage
Most of the hour went on artificial intelligence. Reps asked where the University stands, pointing to a gap between its ambition to lead on AI and the caution many students and staff feel in their faculties, about ethics, the environment and creative work. Kyle said Humanities staff often discourage AI use without knowing much about it, and asked the Vice-Chancellor whether there were plans to develop upskilling and training for academic staff, so that they can confidently help their students use AI productively and appropriately in their academic and research work. Others raised the move to in-person and oral exams on some courses, and asked whether declaring AI use is as rigorous as the ethics checks for other research methods.
In response, the Vice-Chancellor explained that a single University AI policy is difficult, because subjects use AI so differently, and at the current pace of change any policy would quickly become outdated. That is why student feedback matters so much. The tutorial is being strengthened as the place to build critical thinking and to learn how to check what AI tools produce, and how graduate students get something similar is still an open question. She agreed that AI training for staff should be promoted more actively in Humanities. Reps were also pointed to TORCH, the Oxford Research Centre in the Humanities, as a place where these conversations are already happening.
Kyle Siwek, Humanities Postgraduate Research Div Rep, puts a question to the Vice-Chancellor, with Giulia Villa, Humanities Postgraduate Taught Div Rep, far left.
Photo: Michael-Akolade Ayodeji
Opening up the building
Reps said students cannot use the black box studio or the music studios unless a faculty books and pays for the time, which shuts out student-led projects. Colleagues explained that the Division's new Student Music Officer is working to open these spaces up, with an open call for student projects planned and the Division helping with technical and front-of-house costs. Reps asked for daytime rehearsal access to be a priority.
The cost of study
Reps raised the cost of Oxford for international students, including those from the EU, and the need for more master's scholarships, especially in the Humanities, where a master's is often the route to a DPhil. They also pointed out that teaching training for DPhil students is unpaid, despite the preparation it takes, and that Cambridge now pays for it. The Vice-Chancellor said the University would look into paid teaching training. She also explained that graduate scholarships are a key focus of the University's fundraising campaign, which aims to raise £1 billion to fund scholarships for a greater proportion of graduate students, and said she would look at the current balance between master's and DPhil scholarships.
What happens next
Three things came out of the meeting:
- AI training for Humanities staff to be promoted more actively.
- The University to look into paying DPhil students for teaching training.
- Reps to follow up on daytime student access to the studios.
Your Humanities div reps will follow these up through the Division's committees, and we will post updates here.
In pictures

Kyle Siwek makes his point, with Giulia Villa far left.
Photo: Michael-Akolade Ayodeji

Kyle Siwek listens to the panel's answers.
Photo: Michael-Akolade Ayodeji

Evangeli Saha, Humanities Undergraduate Div Rep, with Giulia Villa in the background.
Photo: Michael-Akolade Ayodeji
Our view
"Asking the Vice-Chancellor questions was a unique opportunity not just to raise issues at the highest possible level, but also to hear how the University as a whole institution was interacting with challenges that can sometimes feel confined to specific divisions or faculties. I hope that the students who attended will be able to, like I have, come away with a wider perspective on the issues they brought to the Vice-Chancellor, and a level of confidence that the student voice truly matters to University leadership."
Kyle Siwek, Humanities Postgraduate Research Divisional Rep
"Meeting the Vice-Chancellor was a valuable chance to bring the undergraduate perspective directly to University leadership. Hearing how the issues students raise connect to decisions made across the wider institution gave me a clearer sense of how change actually happens. I hope the conversation leads to concrete follow-up on the concerns undergraduates brought forward, and that students feel confident their voices are being heard at the highest level."
Evangeli Saha, Humanities Undergraduate Divisional Rep
"Meeting with the Vice-Chancellor was a valuable and genuinely insightful experience. It gave me a clearer picture of the pressing issues within our division, as well as the Vice-Chancellor's fresh perspective on how the University should tackle them. It was encouraging to see how engaged divisional and course representatives were throughout the discussion. I came away feeling motivated and ready to use what I learned to shape my agenda for the year ahead."
Giulia Villa, Humanities Postgraduate Taught Divisional Rep
"Reps came prepared with what their coursemates had told them, and the Vice-Chancellor and Professor Grimley did not just listen to criticism, they asked for more of it. They also invited students to work with them on solutions. This meeting showed why student voices matter and how open the University is to listening. Students' views really do shape these decisions."
Michael-Akolade Ayodeji, Student Voice Coordinator
Thank you
Thank you to Professor Tracey, Professor Grimley and Alex Vincent for their time and openness, to Harriet O'Connor and the Humanities Division for organising the meeting, and to every rep who came along and spoke up for their coursemates.
Be part of the solution
The Vice-Chancellor was happy for students to challenge and scrutinise, but asked them to come with solutions too, because that is how things change faster. That is exactly what Student Voice is for. If something about your course or your time at Oxford could be better, tell your course rep: they are your first point of contact. Your div reps take issues to the Division and the University, just as Evangeli, Giulia and Kyle did at the meeting. Meet your Humanities Div Reps on our Instagram, find your reps on the Meet your Reps page, or email studentvoice@oxfordsu.ox.ac.uk.